This New Minecraft 1.14 Block Is Garbage...


Comments • 5 820

  • AntVenom
    AntVenom   6 months back

    Here's what I think. I think the compost bin giving bone-meal is fine. I don't think the "fill up rate" should be random. That much was explained in the video. But just making the bone-meal rate higher wouldn't fix much. How about making it so if a compost bin is in the middle of a farm, the crops around it grow faster, and mushrooms can grow in any light level in a radius surrounding it? That way, the bone-meal drop-rate isn't overpowered, and the block becomes legitimately useful.

    • John Carlo Mananes
      John Carlo Mananes  4 days back

      I think that is a good idea but the composter now is better than you think because it is a very good use in redstone because it is a resource saving way to use cauldrons

    • Taco Mane
      Taco Mane  1 weeks back

      Way late I thought compost bin was more recent but like I hate how when I break it the crops don’t come out I wish we could take them out with shovels and/or hoes

    • Sans 69
      Sans 69  1 weeks back


    • CosyHamster Plays!
      CosyHamster Plays!  2 weeks back

      Please change this Mojang

    • Natalia Bachinskaya
      Natalia Bachinskaya  2 weeks back

      I do not agree 😤😤😡😡😡🤬🤬🤬

  • Nico Says...
    Nico Says...  6 hours back

    Uses a thousand potatoes to make a single bonemeal


    • Orange Zesto
      Orange Zesto  12 hours back

      Who would waste a cake for a bonemeal?

      • Nico Says...
        Nico Says...  6 hours back

        Someone who misread the wiki page I guess

    • Jasir Aljaber
      Jasir Aljaber  17 hours back


      • Kssk •
        Kssk •  22 hours back

        there’s a pun in the title

        • Element XXXI
          Element XXXI  1 days back

          I think it’s great for a dump for all my excess seeds when farming

          • Asadefa
            Asadefa  1 days back

            You get bone meal from composters, which get crafted into white dye. Rotting trash = white dye? Wtf?

            • Asadefa
              Asadefa  1 days back

              I agree sooo much. I can fight skeletons and get many many stacks of bone blocks!

              • c b
                c b  1 days back

                But it can make bonemil farm sooooo

                • Emircan Uauaja
                  Emircan Uauaja  1 days back

                  You don't like them, right ?.. SO CREATE A NEW WORLD, MAKE IT PEACEFUL AND GET BONEMEAL FROM CREATIVE.
                  Look.. Everybody is farming in Minecraft right ?.. A billion seed is coming from just a 4x4 wheat farm. It is annoying to place in chest a tons of useless seeds but you don't want to drop it to lava. This i the perfect thing. You are farming. Seeds coming from farm. Youre feeding chickens and making bonemeal from them. No full 'farm' chests. Full stomach chickens and some bonemal for your not growing acacia tree for 5 days. THIS IS ABSOLUTELY AWESOME. So composter isn't garbage.. its eco-friendly garbage bin.

                  • Crocodile Smash
                    Crocodile Smash  2 days back

                    Composters are extremely useful, I don't get why everybody hates it. I have two farms of Wheat and Sugar Cane and they are extremely useful whenever I don't need extra Seeds or Sugar Cane.

                    • Steven Castaneda
                      Steven Castaneda  2 days back

                      In my opinion it’s great cause I always have too much saplings and seeds so I just put them in the composter

                      • Shrek Ogreton
                        Shrek Ogreton  2 days back

                        I don't see anything wrong with composters.

                        • Willie Boy
                          Willie Boy  2 days back

                          Well, in the meantime it still is a good way to dispose of excess seeds you don't need. That's what I do. And hey, every once and a while you get bone meal from it. I don't see a downside.

                          • Dwayne’s Collections

                            AntVenom: Composter is garbage
                            Me: bonemeal farm LOL

                            • PROSKY yt
                              PROSKY yt  2 days back

                              It could be nice if everything had 100% adding in

                              • Lexi Davis
                                Lexi Davis  3 days back

                                I give the composter about a 1 and that just because you use it for trash.

                                • The new sonic movie is actually coll

                                  At least the composer makes a great dog bowl

                                  • Simrasil
                                    Simrasil  3 days back

                                    I don't really have a problem with it... it's a place to dump all the excess seeds you get from a wheat farm and even get something useful in return

                                    • hacker man
                                      hacker man  3 days back

                                      this composter is f###### garbage

                                      • PlayedLOL XD
                                        PlayedLOL XD  3 days back

                                        for some reason I use it to put blocks and items I don't need Into it and pretend its a bin Lmaof lol

                                        • Dylan Stull
                                          Dylan Stull  3 days back


                                          • David Plaza
                                            David Plaza  3 days back

                                            "And honestly"

                                            • Italiks
                                              Italiks  4 days back

                                              stop babyraging hankvenom

                                              • Patrick Star
                                                Patrick Star  4 days back

                                                You forgot that you can put haybale under the campfire

                                                • MisterNameGame 2
                                                  MisterNameGame 2  14 hours back

                                                  He covered that feature on the 19w02a video, this is a 19w03a video.

                                              • Neil Tycho
                                                Neil Tycho  5 days back

                                                Use wheat seeds you scrubs

                                                Edit: I mean if you find a village cuz it makes things alot easier lol

                                                • XBGamerX 20
                                                  XBGamerX 20  5 days back

                                                  Composters are useful to trap people after using a trapdoor onto it.

                                                  • Vee Cohens
                                                    Vee Cohens  5 days back

                                                    What about pocket edition is this for java or both

                                                    • Kael
                                                      Kael  5 days back

                                                      at least you can trap your friends in it

                                                      • michael mann
                                                        michael mann  5 days back

                                                        At the time of uploading this was it not a villager job site yet? Cus it’s way more useful for villages than actual use for your farms.

                                                        But I do get it peaceful players get kinda screwed. But why play in peaceful. Unless you are under the age of 10 you should at least play easy. And even then why play the game cus a large part of the game is fighting mobs.

                                                        • Phiraphon Pong
                                                          Phiraphon Pong  5 days back

                                                          Is it a whoosh or hopper isn't your thing?

                                                          • Skrrt
                                                            Skrrt  5 days back

                                                            Atleast you Can now use the leftover seeds and plants that you would get rid of stop crying

                                                            • Patrick Chang
                                                              Patrick Chang  5 days back

                                                              If you have a bunch of afk farms, and items you don’t need, just put a hopper system into the compost bin.

                                                              • X&Y Gaming
                                                                X&Y Gaming  5 days back

                                                                That's what this is for?!
                                                                I keep seeing them in a corner of a village's farm and so I just put one in every corner :|

                                                                • HeroMichael
                                                                  HeroMichael  6 days back

                                                                  just hook It up to a wheat farm and bam infinite bonemeal

                                                                  • TompyGamer CZ
                                                                    TompyGamer CZ  6 days back

                                                                    I would be super happy with it if it worked with hoppers. Everytime i harvest my field, i have like 3 stacks of excess seeds. It's a pain in the ass to click on the composter with every single one, though it would be much better if i could just throw them into a hopper leading to the composter, which would throw out a bone meal when filled that could be forwarded into another hopper. I think it could accept rotten flesh, for me it wouldn't be very useful, though, since i give my rotten flesh to the cleric for emeralds.

                                                                    • Cream puff Diancie
                                                                      Cream puff Diancie  6 days back

                                                                      this be perfect for me cause I'm too scared to go to survival ;^;

                                                                      • diamondprince 7718
                                                                        diamondprince 7718  6 days back

                                                                        i give it a 3

                                                                        • MurtGaming
                                                                          MurtGaming  6 days back

                                                                          Eh, put it in a wheat farm and put in extra seeds you have

                                                                          • KriK Mo
                                                                            KriK Mo  7 days back

                                                                            Map seed??

                                                                            • Yankee Doodler
                                                                              Yankee Doodler  7 days back

                                                                              I'm just mad that I cant put rotten flesh in it.

                                                                              • Donedidgamer Yeet
                                                                                Donedidgamer Yeet  7 days back

                                                                                *uses 153 wheat for a peace of bonemeal*

                                                                                *uses on single peace of wheat*

                                                                                • VerdanaDaSkele
                                                                                  VerdanaDaSkele  7 days back

                                                                                  I need to lay down in pe tho, tell me how

                                                                                  • Mundonnable
                                                                                    Mundonnable  7 days back

                                                                                    The thing about the composter is that it's for useless stuff that you don't want or need anymore. Like for example I normally have a smaller farm and I normally end up with a crazy amount of seeds of all kinds. That is counting, wheat, pumpkin, beets, and all the other kind that just sit there. Since I don't really need a bigger farm those seeds just sit there so instead of just them sitting there I can just put them in the composter. I mean not killing any extra skeletons I end up with a lot more bone meal than normal.

                                                                                    Like its not for items like a cake, the main use of the composter is to throw extra stuff in it. Not for you to go out of your way to fill it up to get bone meal, now like many have said before. I do believe it should be added that you can use rotten flesh with it but other than that I think its just fine.

                                                                                    • MetaDragon
                                                                                      MetaDragon  1 weeks back

                                                                                      On a scale of 1 - 8, I give it a 153

                                                                                      • Nathan The savage
                                                                                        Nathan The savage  1 weeks back

                                                                                        This day is my b day!

                                                                                        • v1ni jigz
                                                                                          v1ni jigz  1 weeks back

                                                                                          I love it, it's like a trash can! I throw saplings in them and the disappear after a while down in the composter.

                                                                                          edit: I throw things in it and they disappear.

                                                                                          • Jerry W
                                                                                            Jerry W  1 weeks back

                                                                                            I just use it to dispose my sweet berries